博客

[FCE] Meta and YouTube designed addictive products that harmed young people, jury finds

收听本期播客

阅读正文

In a significant legal development, a Los Angeles jury has reached a landmark decision, finding tech giants Meta and YouTube liable for intentionally designing addictive products that caused harm to a young user. The verdict concluded that both companies were negligent and failed to provide adequate warnings about the potential dangers associated with their social media platforms. This ruling marks a crucial moment as it is the first lawsuit of its kind concerning the alleged harm of social media on young individuals to proceed to trial.

The plaintiff in the case, identified as KGM, was awarded a substantial $6 million in damages. Meta has been ordered to pay 70% of this sum, with YouTube responsible for the remaining amount. During the six-week trial, jurors heard powerful testimony from KGM, who recounted becoming addicted to YouTube by age six and Instagram by age nine. She described experiencing severe depression and engaging in self-harm by the age of ten, alongside strained family relationships. KGM was also diagnosed with body dysmorphic disorder and social phobia, conditions she attributed directly to her extensive social media use.

KGM’s legal team argued that the companies deliberately engineered their products to be addictive. They likened specific features, such as the infinitely scrollable feed and video autoplay functions, to “Trojan horses” – features designed to captivate young users deceptively. The lawyers drew parallels to historical lawsuits against the tobacco industry, where companies faced accusations of public denial despite possessing knowledge of their products’ harmful qualities.

Both Meta and YouTube have voiced strong disagreement with the jury’s decision and intend to appeal the ruling. A Meta spokesperson stated that teen mental health is “profoundly complex” and cannot be solely attributed to a single application. YouTube, in its defence, maintained it is a “responsibly built streaming platform, not a social media site.” This verdict follows another recent judgment against Meta, in which the company was ordered to pay $375 million in civil penalties in a separate New Mexico lawsuit for misleading consumers and enabling harm. These consecutive rulings represent the initial instances where Meta has been held accountable for the adverse impact of its products on younger individuals. KGM’s case is also one of over twenty “bellwether” trials, which are designed to test legal theories and establish precedents for numerous similar cases anticipated in the future.

阅读练习

1. What is the primary focus of the article?

  • A. The difficulties tech companies face in balancing innovation with user safety.
  • B. A significant legal case finding tech companies liable for harm caused by addictive social media.
  • C. The history of lawsuits comparing social media companies to the tobacco industry.
  • D. The various mental health issues experienced by young social media users.

2. According to the verdict, what percentage of the awarded damages is Meta responsible for paying?

  • A. 30%
  • B. 60%
  • C. 70%
  • D. 100%

3. The lawyers’ comparison of social media features to “Trojan horses” suggests that these features are:

  • A. advanced technological innovations.
  • B. openly advertised as potentially dangerous.
  • C. designed to be appealing while concealing harmful intentions.
  • D. harmless tools when used responsibly by young people.

4. In the context of the article, what does the term “bellwether trials” most closely refer to?

  • A. Trials that predict future weather patterns.
  • B. Initial cases that help determine the outcome of many similar future cases.
  • C. Legal proceedings focused on agricultural disputes.
  • D. Trials that only involve the testimony of young plaintiffs.

5. Which of the following conditions did KGM attribute to her social media use?

  • A. Physical injuries and financial loss.
  • B. Depression, self-harm, and body dysmorphic disorder.
  • C. Academic failure and professional setbacks.
  • D. Allergies and sleep disorders.